If your employer's plan shows you an "account balance" but calls itself a cash balance plan, you are in a pension, not a 401(k). It is a defined benefit plan: the employer funds it, bears the investment risk and promises the benefit the plan's formula produces. Your balance is a bookkeeping figure that grows by pay credits and interest credits.
Many participants first notice a cash balance plan when a statement arrives that does not match what they expected: an interest credit lower than last year's, a lump sum figure that seems short, or an opening balance from an old pension conversion that never seemed to move. Those are fair questions to bring to the plan's own documents. Under federal law in the United States, the answer turns on the plan document, the statute and the record the plan keeps, and each of those can be read.
What a Cash Balance Plan Is, and Why It Is Not Your 401(k)
When you look at a cash balance statement, the number resembles a 401(k) balance, but the law treats it as a pension. A cash balance plan is a defined benefit plan under ERISA, not a defined contribution plan, and the employer bears the investment risk.
Each year the plan credits your hypothetical account (an account that exists on paper to measure your benefit) with two things: a pay credit, usually a percentage of compensation, and an interest credit at a rate the plan document sets. No money sits in a separate account in your name. The plan holds its assets in a single trust, which under 26 U.S.C. § 401 must exist for the exclusive benefit of employees and their beneficiaries.
The contrast with other plans is the point. In a 401(k), you bear the investment risk; if the funds fall, your account falls. In a cash balance plan, the employer bears it, because your credited balance does not depend on how the trust's investments perform. A traditional pension states the benefit as a monthly annuity formula, such as years of service times final salary times a multiplier. A cash balance plan states it as an account balance that can be converted into an annuity at retirement.
Title I of ERISA governs fiduciary duties, reporting and disclosure; Title IV governs termination insurance through the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation (PBGC). The Department of Labor and the IRS share regulatory jurisdiction. Coverage depends on the sponsor: governmental and church plans may fall outside ERISA.
How Your Balance Grows: Pay Credits and Interest Credits
Reading your own statement starts with two lines. The pay credit is the amount the employer adds each year, a stated percentage of your compensation or another formula the plan document specifies. The interest credit is a rate the plan applies to the balance already in the account. The plan document may set that rate as a fixed figure, tie it to a Treasury index or tie it to another benchmark it names.
The Pension Protection Act of 2006, Pub. L. 109-280 (PPA 2006), set rules for those interest credits. It limits the rate to no more than a market rate of return and, in general, protects the balance from being reduced below the pay credits that were credited. Before PPA 2006, some plans faced a problem known as "whipsaw": converting a balance to a lump sum by projecting it forward and discounting it back could produce a figure different from the stated balance. PPA 2006 allowed plans meeting the market-rate rules to pay the stated balance.
Those details are why the plan document matters. A statement is checkable: the pay credit percentage and interest credit rate applied in each year can be compared against the formula the plan document states.
Vesting (the point at which your benefit cannot be forfeited) is governed by ERISA's minimum vesting standards, 29 U.S.C. § 1053, which also set how years of service are counted and which years a plan may disregard, such as service before age 18. The plan document and summary plan description state the schedule that applies to your plan.
What ERISA Protects in a Cash Balance Plan
If you have earned a balance, the first protection is that it cannot simply be taken back. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1054(g), "the accrued benefit of a participant under a plan may not be decreased by an amendment of the plan," with narrow statutory exceptions, and eliminating an early retirement subsidy or an optional form of benefit for past service counts as a reduction.
Disclosure is the second. ERISA entitles participants to a summary plan description, periodic benefit statements and a summary annual report, and to request a statement of accrued and vested benefits.
Fiduciary duty is the third. Plan assets sit in trust, and the people who control them must, under 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1), act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries," for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan," with the care of a prudent person and by diversifying investments to minimize the risk of large losses. A fiduciary (a person who exercises discretionary control over the plan or its money) is identified by function, not title; the ERISA fiduciary breach duties apply whoever holds that control.
PBGC insurance is the fourth: as defined benefit plans, cash balance plans are covered by termination insurance up to statutory limits. Enforcement runs through 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a), which lets a participant sue to recover benefits, enforce plan terms or seek relief for fiduciary breaches.
PPA 2006 also addressed age discrimination, providing in general that a cash balance plan is not treated as age-discriminatory merely because of how its interest credits work, so long as the plan's terms meet the Act's conditions.
When Your Employer Converted a Traditional Pension to Cash Balance
For a participant who was in a traditional pension when the employer switched formulas, the conversion date is often where the questions begin. A conversion is a plan amendment that replaces the old formula with a cash balance formula, and the anti-cutback rule in § 1054(g) requires the benefit already accrued under the old formula to be preserved.
At conversion, plans typically set an opening hypothetical balance meant to reflect the present value of the old accrued benefit. The method and assumptions used for that figure matter a great deal.
Wear-away is the problem that follows when the new formula starts below what the old benefit was worth. Picture a participant whose old formula produced an accrued benefit of a certain value at conversion, while the opening balance was set lower. The participant keeps the old protected benefit, but new cash balance credits must first close the gap before they add anything. For years, the participant may earn no new net benefit. Participants close to retirement at conversion were the most exposed, and wear-away drew litigation and regulatory attention.
PPA 2006 addressed this for conversions it covers, generally requiring that a participant's benefit be at least the old accrued benefit plus the benefit earned under the new formula, so the two are not offset against each other. Separately, ERISA requires advance written notice to participants before a plan amendment that significantly reduces the rate of future benefit accrual.
Your Distribution Options: Annuity, Lump Sum and Rollover
If you are leaving employment or approaching retirement, the plan document decides how the benefit can be paid, within limits ERISA sets. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1055, a plan must provide a qualified joint and survivor annuity, and for a married participant that annuity is the default unless the spouse consents in writing to a different form. The same section defines a preretirement survivor annuity for a spouse when a participant dies before retirement.
Many cash balance plans also offer a lump sum equal to the hypothetical balance. Whether yours does is a question for the plan document and the summary plan description; the statute does not require it.
A lump sum from a qualified plan can generally be rolled over to an IRA or another qualified plan, and the Internal Revenue Code sets the tax and withholding rules for distributions, including additional tax on many distributions taken before age 59½ unless an exception applies. Those rules carry tax consequences that depend on individual circumstances and are not addressed here.
A participant who leaves before retirement age with a vested benefit generally keeps a deferred vested benefit: the balance can remain in the plan until normal retirement age, or be paid earlier as a lump sum if the plan permits. A written statement of accrued and vested benefits, which ERISA allows a participant to request, shows the figures the plan is using.
How the Plan Is Funded, and the IRS Limits That Apply
When you compare a cash balance plan with a 401(k), the funding runs the other way. The employer funds the plan; participants do not contribute.
ERISA's minimum funding standards, 29 U.S.C. §§ 1082 and 1083, require the employer to fund the promised benefits, with parallel rules in the Internal Revenue Code. Section 1083(c) allows the Treasury to waive the standard for temporary substantial business hardship, but not more than 3 times in any 15 consecutive plan years for a single-employer plan. Section 1083 imposes stricter funding assumptions on a plan "in at-risk status."
Funding matters to you directly. Under the Code, when a plan's adjusted funding target attainment percentage (AFTAP, a measure of how well funded the plan is) falls below certain thresholds, the plan must restrict or suspend lump sum payments and, at lower levels, benefit accruals.
The Code also caps benefits. Under 26 U.S.C. § 415(b), the limit is applied to the benefit expressed as an annual benefit in the form of a straight life annuity, so it measures the annuity equivalent of the balance, not the balance itself. A separate Code limit caps the compensation used in the pay credit formula. Both are adjusted periodically; the current figures appear on the IRS retirement plans page.
ERISA requires the plan administrator to send an annual funding notice describing the plan's funding status.
When Your Statement Looks Wrong: Common Problems and What ERISA Allows
By the time a participant notices that a number is off, the question is usually which kind of problem it is, because ERISA treats them differently.
A calculation error, such as an interest credit rate that does not match the plan document or a wrong pay credit percentage, is a benefit claim. Section 1132(a)(1)(B) allows a participant to sue "to recover benefits due to him under the terms of his plan." A denied lump sum the plan document offers falls in the same category.
A conversion that reduced accrued benefits in violation of § 1054(g) can support a claim; courts have addressed wear-away and opening-balance methods in such cases, and outcomes have turned on each plan's terms.
Mismanagement of plan assets, such as imprudent investments or excessive plan fees, is a fiduciary-breach matter. Under § 1132(a)(2), such a claim seeks relief under § 1109 restoring losses to the plan, and § 1132(a)(3) allows "other appropriate equitable relief."
ERISA requires every plan to have a claims procedure with notice and review. Whether a participant must use it before suing is a court-made rule: courts generally require it before a benefit claim, and most circuits do not before a statutory fiduciary-breach claim.
Deadlines depend on the claim. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1113, a fiduciary-breach claim must be brought by the earlier of six years after the last act of the breach (or, for an omission, the last date it could have been cured) or three years after the plaintiff's actual knowledge, with six years from discovery in cases of fraud or concealment. Benefit claims may be governed by the plan's own terms and a period courts apply. Which applies depends on the facts.
The Three Agencies That Oversee Cash Balance Plans
If you are trying to find where official information about your plan lives, three federal agencies divide the work.
The Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration enforces ERISA's fiduciary, reporting and disclosure rules. The IRS administers the Code's tax-qualification rules, including the vesting, benefit-limit and funding provisions, and publishes participant and sponsor material on its retirement plans pages. An employer may ask the IRS for a determination letter confirming the plan's qualified status, and the plan administrator can say whether a current letter exists.
The Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation insures defined benefit plan benefits if a plan terminates without enough assets, publishes its guarantee limits, which change each year, and maintains a searchable list of terminated plans. The PBGC does not insure 401(k) or 403(b) accounts.
The plan's own record is in its annual Form 5500, which the Department of Labor makes searchable through EFAST2. The filing, identified by sponsor, EIN and plan number, reports assets, liabilities and, for a defined benefit plan, actuarial and funding schedules for the plan year. Those filings are where questions about funding and recordkeeping and administrative fees start to have answers.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.