If a fund in your retirement plan keeps lagging or costs more than similar funds, the legal question is not whether it lost money. ERISA asks whether the people running the plan chose and kept that fund through a careful, informed process. An investment is imprudent when it was selected or retained without the investigation and judgment a knowledgeable person would use.
Perhaps you noticed a fund near the bottom of your statement year after year, or read that participants in your employer's plan have filed suit. Either way, you are asking a fair question about money you set aside over a working life. The answer turns on duties the law places on the plan's decision-makers and on a record that can, in large part, be checked.
What the prudence duty requires of the people running your plan
When you look at your plan's fund lineup, someone chose it. That person or committee is usually a fiduciary: a person or entity that exercises discretionary authority or control over the plan's management or its money, and who must act only in the participants' interest. The plan sponsor is the employer or organization that set up the plan. The sponsor and the fiduciaries can overlap, but the label follows function, not job title.
ERISA Section 404(a)(1)(B), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1)(B), requires a fiduciary to act "with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use in the conduct of an enterprise of a like character and with like aims."
The words "familiar with such matters" matter. The measure is not an ordinary careful person but someone who knows how retirement investments work, which is why the standard is often called a prudent expert standard.
The duty governs process. Performance is what a fund returned; process is how fiduciaries investigated, compared and decided. A fund can lose value after a sound decision, and a bad result alone does not prove a breach. The duty is also ongoing: it does not end on the day a fund is added. For more on the duties generally, see our guide to ERISA fiduciary breach.
One threshold point: governmental plans and most church plans can fall outside ERISA's fiduciary rules, so coverage depends on the plan and its sponsor.
What courts look at when an investment is called imprudent
Suppose your plan offers a large-company stock fund that has trailed comparable funds for years and charges more. Courts asked whether such a choice was imprudent tend to examine the same kinds of conduct:
- Failure to investigate. Selecting funds without adequate due diligence into their costs, management and alternatives.
- Retaining underperformers without review. Keeping a lagging fund with no documented reason for doing so.
- High expense ratios. An expense ratio is the yearly fee a fund charges, expressed as a percentage of the money invested. Complaints often allege a plan kept costly funds when comparable lower-cost options existed. ERISA sets no numeric fee cap; courts look at the fiduciaries' process, the services and the alternatives in context. Our page on 401(k) excessive fees covers this further.
- Share class. A share class is a version of the same mutual fund with its own fee structure. Participants have alleged that plans offered retail share classes when cheaper institutional classes of the same fund were available.
- Proprietary funds. A recordkeeper is the company that keeps the accounts and runs the plan website. Claims sometimes allege that funds managed by the sponsor or the recordkeeper were included because they benefited that company rather than participants.
- Revenue sharing. This is a fund paying part of its fee to the recordkeeper or another provider, an arrangement that can create a conflict of interest if not examined.
- No documentation. A committee with no record of how it chose or reviewed funds has difficulty showing a prudent process.
Imprudence is judged by what fiduciaries knew or could have learned at the time of the decision, not with hindsight.
How the Supreme Court has applied the prudence standard
If your employer's plan has been sued, two Supreme Court decisions likely shape how that case is argued.
In Tibble v. Edison Int'l, 575 U.S. 523 (2015), the participants alleged the plan kept higher-cost retail share classes. The Court held that a fiduciary has a continuing duty to monitor investments and remove imprudent ones, separate from the duty at initial selection. It followed that a claim based on a failure to monitor within the limitations period could be timely even though the funds were first added earlier. The Court sent the case back for the lower courts to apply that rule.
In Hughes v. Northwestern Univ., 595 U.S. 170 (2022), participants in two university retirement plans alleged imprudent fees and investment options. The Seventh Circuit had affirmed dismissal partly because participants could choose low-cost funds. The Supreme Court vacated that judgment, holding that offering some prudent options does not by itself defeat claims that other options were imprudent, and remanded. Lower courts continue to decide at the motion-to-dismiss stage whether a complaint plausibly alleges imprudence, in the context of each case.
The Department of Labor has issued guidance and filed amicus briefs in significant prudence cases. Its resources are collected by the Employee Benefits Security Administration.
The time limit, ERISA Section 413, 29 U.S.C. § 1113, is discussed in the last section below.
Why ongoing review of the fund lineup matters
For a participant whose plan has offered the same funds for a decade, Tibble is the key point: the duty to monitor did not expire when those funds were picked.
A monitoring process typically involves periodic review of each fund's performance, fees and available alternatives, with a record of what was decided and why. Many committees use an Investment Policy Statement (IPS), the written document a plan committee uses to govern how investments are selected and reviewed. Courts examining prudence claims have noted where no IPS existed or where a committee did not follow its own.
Target-date funds receive the same scrutiny. These are funds that automatically shift their mix of stocks and bonds as a participant approaches a target retirement year. Many plans use them as the default investment, so how a target-date series was chosen and reviewed is a prudence question like any other.
Committees often hire an investment consultant or adviser. Whether that adviser is itself a fiduciary depends on what it does, such as giving investment advice for a fee. Delegating does not end the committee's own duty: it remains responsible for prudently choosing and monitoring the adviser.
Who can bring a claim, and what the law allows a court to order
If you are a participant or a beneficiary (a person entitled to benefits under the plan, such as a surviving spouse), ERISA Section 502(a)(2), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(2), allows you to sue, as does the Secretary of Labor or a fiduciary, "for appropriate relief under section 1109."
That relief runs to the plan. ERISA Section 409, 29 U.S.C. § 1109, makes a fiduciary who breaches its duties "personally liable to make good to such plan any losses to the plan resulting from each such breach," to restore profits made through use of plan assets, and subject to "other equitable or remedial relief as the court may deem appropriate, including removal of such fiduciary." Restored losses reach participants through the plan and their accounts, not as a personal damages award. Because the claim is plan-wide, these cases often proceed as class actions.
Section 502(a)(3), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3), separately allows a participant, beneficiary or fiduciary to seek an injunction or "other appropriate equitable relief." The court may also allow a reasonable attorney's fee and costs to either party under § 1132(g)(1).
The Department of Labor enforces these duties alongside private suits.
A lawsuit's claims are allegations. A filed complaint, or a ruling that it may proceed, is not a finding that anyone breached a duty. A settlement resolves a case, generally without a finding of liability.
What participants can look at when an investment raises questions
When your statement raises a question, much of the relevant record is already public or available on request.
The Summary Plan Description (SPD) is the plain-language document explaining how the plan works, and participants can request it from the plan administrator along with other governing documents. The Form 5500 is the annual report a plan files with the Department of Labor disclosing assets, service providers and certain fees; filings can be searched through the DOL's EFAST2 system.
Fund expense ratios and share classes appear in fund prospectuses and in the plan's 404(a)(5) fee disclosure, the notice participant-directed plans give describing each investment option's costs. Some participants compare those figures with published category averages, such as Morningstar's, as informational context. A comparison is a starting point, not a conclusion, and not investment advice.
Time matters. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1113, a fiduciary-breach claim is barred after the earlier of six years from the last action that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the latest date it could have been cured), or three years from the earliest date the plaintiff had actual knowledge of it. Where there was fraud or concealment, suit may be brought up to six years after discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts.
ERLG handles ERISA fiduciary-breach claims on behalf of participants and beneficiaries. This site gives no investment advice and does not tell anyone what to invest in. What a 401(k) lawyer reviews is the plan's record and its decisions.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.