If you have heard that a retirement plan "failed to monitor," it refers to a specific ERISA duty. A fiduciary who appoints someone else to run part of the plan, or who picks the plan's investments, must keep reviewing those people and choices over time and act when they stop being prudent. Choosing well once is not enough.
A participant who has seen a lawsuit filed against an employer's plan, or who has watched the same funds sit in an account year after year, is asking a reasonable question. The answer starts with the duty itself, then with who carries it, and then with what the plan's own records can show. None of that assumes anything about a particular plan. It describes what federal law requires of the people who run one.
What Failure to Monitor Means for Your Plan Under ERISA
When your plan lists a committee, a trustee or a manager, each of them answers to someone. A fiduciary is a person or entity that exercises discretionary authority or control over a plan or its assets. Status is functional: someone is a fiduciary to the extent they do those things. The plan sponsor is typically the employer that establishes and maintains the plan.
The root is ERISA § 404(a)(1), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1). It requires a fiduciary to act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries" and "with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use." The words "then prevailing" matter. Prudence is judged at each point in time, not only on the day a choice was made.
That is why selection and monitoring are different duties. A fund or recordkeeper can be a sound choice in one year and a poor one later.
Delegation is the second root. Under ERISA § 405(c)(2), 29 U.S.C. § 1105(c)(2), a named fiduciary who properly allocates or delegates a responsibility is generally not liable for the appointee's acts, except to the extent the named fiduciary violated § 404(a)(1) in making the allocation, in setting up or carrying out the procedure, or "in continuing the allocation or designation." That last clause is the statutory foothold of the monitoring claim.
Which Fiduciaries Carry the Duty to Monitor in a Plan Like Yours
Who, in a plan like yours, is supposed to be watching? Usually it begins with the plan sponsor. An employer that appoints an investment committee, or hires a recordkeeper (the firm that tracks account balances and processes transactions), keeps a duty to review whether those appointments still make sense.
Investment committee members are commonly the named fiduciaries for investment decisions in 401(k) and 403(b) plan documents. Whether that is true of a particular plan depends on its documents, which the plan's governing instrument and summary plan description identify.
Trustees vary. A directed trustee follows instructions from another fiduciary and is generally not responsible for the underlying investment decision, though courts have considered whether a directed trustee must raise obvious problems. The answer depends on the facts and the court.
An investment manager the plan formally appoints with authority over plan assets changes the picture without ending it. The sponsor's exposure for the manager's individual decisions narrows, but under § 405(c)(2) the duty to review whether the appointment should continue remains. A recordkeeper or manager may or may not be a fiduciary for a given act; the functional test decides.
In disputes, courts look at concrete markers: how often the committee met, whether reviews were documented, and whether there was a process for replacing underperforming funds or providers. Any plan language claiming to relieve a fiduciary of these duties is generally void under 29 U.S.C. § 1110(a).
How Federal Courts Have Read the Failure-to-Monitor Claim
If you have seen a ruling in the news, it helps to know the case most often cited. In Tibble v. Edison Int'l, 575 U.S. 523 (2015), the U.S. Supreme Court held that a fiduciary has a continuing duty to monitor plan investments and remove imprudent ones, separate from the duty to choose them carefully. In plain terms: keeping a fund is a decision too.
Tibble also bears on timing. The Court held that a claim alleging a breach of that continuing duty within the six-year period of ERISA § 413, 29 U.S.C. § 1113, can be timely even if the fund was first selected earlier. It left the details of the continuing duty for the lower courts. How far that reaches depends on the facts and the circuit.
Pleading matters early. Under the federal pleading standard, a complaint must allege facts making the claim plausible, not merely possible. Federal district courts look for specifics about what the monitoring process lacked, not just a bad result.
The claim is usually derivative. It generally requires an underlying breach by the appointee; if that claim is dismissed, the monitoring claim often falls with it.
Approaches differ by circuit. Some courts ask what specific warning signs the monitoring fiduciary ignored; others focus on whether a prudent review process existed at all. In excessive-fee suits filed since 2020, participants have often alleged that fiduciaries kept retail share classes when institutional versions of the same funds were available. Those are allegations; what any court decided turns on that case's record.
Fact Patterns Participants Have Alleged in Monitoring Cases
By the time a participant notices something odd on a statement, it often resembles a pattern already raised in court. Each one below describes what participants have alleged in various cases, not what any court found about any plan.
Share classes. An expense ratio is the annual fee a fund charges, expressed as a percentage of assets. Many funds sell several share classes of the same portfolio at different expense ratios. Complaints have alleged that fiduciaries kept higher-cost retail classes when lower-cost institutional classes were available. ERISA sets no numeric fee cap; the question is the process the fiduciaries followed. More on that appears under 401(k) excessive fees.
Target-date funds. A target-date fund automatically shifts its investment mix as the participant approaches a chosen retirement year. Participants have alleged that a suite was kept despite long underperformance against comparable options.
Recordkeeping and revenue sharing. Revenue sharing means payments a fund company makes to a recordkeeper out of fund assets, which can raise the effective cost to participants. Complaints have alleged that recordkeeping fees paid this way were never compared against the market.
Appointed managers. Some suits allege a failure to monitor a manager who concentrated assets in one sector or in affiliated funds.
Pensions. In a defined benefit plan, an accrued benefit is the retirement benefit a participant has earned to date under the plan's formula. Allegations there have involved actuarial assumptions or funding decisions.
What the Department of Labor Says About Monitoring Your Plan's Providers
You may wonder whether monitoring is only a lawyer's theory. The U.S. Department of Labor's Employee Benefits Security Administration treats selecting and monitoring service providers as a core fiduciary act. Its publication Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities describes reviewing plan investments and providers periodically under an established process.
Fees connect to this through ERISA § 408(b)(2), 29 U.S.C. § 1108(b)(2). It permits a plan to contract with a party in interest for services "necessary for the establishment or operation of the plan, if no more than reasonable compensation is paid therefor." Fiduciaries generally receive compensation information from their providers. A committee that never reviewed it may find that fact cited as evidence of a monitoring failure.
The emphasis is on process. A fiduciary who follows a prudent process may not be liable even if an investment loses value. A fiduciary with no process may face a claim even if an investment happened to do well. Agency guidance can be updated, and the EBSA site is the place to check its current form.
Remedies the Statute Provides If a Monitoring Failure Is Proved
For a participant reading about remedies, the first point is whose loss is being repaired. Under ERISA § 409(a), 29 U.S.C. § 1109(a), a breaching fiduciary is "personally liable to make good to such plan any losses to the plan resulting from each such breach, and to restore to such plan any profits" made through use of plan assets. The same section allows "other equitable or remedial relief as the court may deem appropriate, including removal of such fiduciary."
The claim belongs to the plan. ERISA § 502(a)(2) lets a participant sue for relief under § 409. In a defined contribution plan, where each participant has an individual account, such as a 401(k) or 403(b), a restored amount flows into the plan and is then allocated to affected accounts. It is not a personal award.
ERISA § 502(a)(3), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(3), allows a suit to enjoin a violation or obtain "other appropriate equitable relief." Courts have used this to require changes going forward, such as a monitoring process.
ERISA also gives courts discretion to award reasonable attorney's fees and costs in these actions. That is a feature of the statute, not a prediction. Defined benefit pensions are insured by the PBGC within limits; 401(k) and 403(b) accounts are not. The fuller picture of these claims sits under ERISA fiduciary breach.
What Can Be Checked If a Monitoring Failure Seems Possible
When a participant recognizes one of these patterns, the record usually tells more than the news does. First, coverage: ERISA is federal law that applies nationwide and generally preempts state law for covered plans, but governmental plans and most church plans fall outside it. A public school or church employee's plan may not be an ERISA plan.
The plan document and summary plan description come first. ERISA generally gives participants the right to request the governing documents from the plan administrator in writing.
The Form 5500 is the plan's annual federal filing, publicly searchable through the Department of Labor's Form 5500 page. It reports plan assets, service providers and their compensation for each plan year.
Account statements and fee notices show fund names, expense ratios and changes to the lineup over time.
Timing is set by ERISA § 413. A claim must be brought by the earlier of six years after the last act that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the last date it could have been cured) or three years after the participant's actual knowledge of it. In cases of fraud or concealment, the period is six years from discovery. Tibble's continuing-duty reasoning can affect which acts fall inside the window. Which period applies depends on the facts.
Employee Retirement Litigation Group offers a no-obligation review of what a plan's filings and documents show; an initial review is typically completed within a few business days. What a 401(k) lawyer does with that review is described elsewhere on this site.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.