An ESOP fiduciary breach happens when someone who controls your employee stock ownership plan or its money fails a duty ERISA imposes. Those duties are loyalty, prudence, diversification where it applies, and following the plan's documents. The most common ESOP claim alleges that the plan paid more than fair market value for company stock.
Perhaps you read that your employer's ESOP has been sued, or your statement shows a share value that dropped sharply after a buyout. You may simply want to know what the trustee owes you. The questions that matter are what the duty requires, what the plan's own record shows, and what the law allows when a duty is not met.
What an ESOP Fiduciary Breach Means for Your Plan
If your retirement savings sit in an ESOP, an Employee Stock Ownership Plan, you are in a defined contribution plan that invests primarily in the stock of the company you work for. Because it is a defined contribution plan, your ESOP account is not insured by the federal pension insurer, the PBGC. That insurer covers defined benefit pensions.
A fiduciary is a person or entity who exercises discretionary authority or control over the plan's management or its assets, or who gives investment advice for a fee. The test looks at function, not job title. The same person can be a fiduciary for one decision and not for another. In an ESOP, the roles that usually carry fiduciary status are:
- the plan trustee, often an independent trustee hired for a leveraged ESOP (a buyout financed with borrowed money);
- the plan administrator; and
- any named fiduciary identified in the plan document.
Whether a particular company held any of those roles depends on the plan's documents and what it actually did.
The core duties come from ERISA § 404(a), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a). A breach is an act, or a failure to act, that violates one of those duties. Courts have often described ERISA's fiduciary standard as among the highest duties known to American law. ESOP fiduciary duties carry their own valuation and loyalty issues. Coverage also depends on who sponsors the plan: governmental and church plans may fall outside these rules.
The Four Duties Your ESOP's Fiduciaries Owe You
Every decision a fiduciary makes about your ESOP is measured against four obligations in 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1). The statute requires a fiduciary to act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries."
Loyalty (§ 1104(a)(1)(A)). The fiduciary must act "for the exclusive purpose of" providing benefits to participants and beneficiaries and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." The plan sponsor (the employer that establishes and maintains the plan) often sits on the other side of an ESOP stock sale. Loyalty requires the trustee to represent participants, not the seller.
Prudence (§ 1104(a)(1)(B)). The fiduciary must act "with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence" that "a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use." This is often called a prudent expert standard. In an ESOP purchase, prudence generally means investigating the stock's worth with an independent valuation. An allegation that a trustee paid more than fair market value is the classic ESOP prudence claim.
Diversification (§ 1104(a)(1)(C)). Fiduciaries must generally diversify investments "so as to minimize the risk of large losses." Section 1104(a)(2) relaxes this for an eligible individual account plan holding qualifying employer securities. Under that subsection, the diversification duty, and prudence only to the extent it requires diversification, is not violated by holding that stock. Loyalty, the rest of prudence and the price paid still apply.
Plan documents (§ 1104(a)(1)(D)). Fiduciaries must follow the plan's governing documents, but only "insofar as" those documents are consistent with ERISA.
How ESOP Breach Claims Usually Arise
When a lawsuit against an ESOP appears in the news, the complaint usually describes one of a handful of recurring patterns. Each is an allegation until a court decides otherwise.
- Overvaluation at the transaction. Participants allege the trustee approved a purchase price above fair market value. The plan then holds stock worth less than it paid.
- Inadequate valuation. Complaints allege the trustee relied on a valuation that was not independent, used stale or optimistic projections, or went unquestioned.
- Prohibited transactions. Participants allege dealings between the plan and insiders that no exemption covers. The next section explains these rules.
- Failure to monitor. A fiduciary who appoints a trustee or hires service providers keeps a duty to oversee them. Complaints allege that leaving an imprudent trustee or recordkeeper (the company that keeps the accounts) in place was itself a breach.
- Excessive fees. Participants allege the plan paid service providers without a prudent process for weighing cost against quality. ERISA sets no numeric fee cap; courts examine the process and the alternatives.
Across all of these, courts focus on process. A bad result from a careful, informed process is not automatically a breach. A good result from a flawed process can still be one.
The Department of Labor has also entered agreements with ESOP trustees that set out process standards for valuing employer stock and using independent financial advisers. The Employee Benefits Security Administration is the agency behind that work. Broader patterns appear in 401(k) plan mismanagement, and the elements of a claim are covered in fiduciary breach under ERISA.
Why Some ESOP Stock Purchases Are Allowed and Others Are Not
Your ESOP exists to buy company stock, often from the owners who run the company. Without an exemption, that purchase would be barred.
A party in interest is someone close to the plan. Examples include the employer, its officers and directors, significant shareholders and the plan's service providers. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1106(a), a fiduciary may not cause the plan to engage in a transaction it "knows or should know" is a direct or indirect:
- sale, exchange or lease of property between the plan and a party in interest;
- loan or extension of credit between them;
- furnishing of goods, services or facilities between them;
- transfer of plan assets to, or use by or for the benefit of, a party in interest; or
- acquisition of employer securities or employer real property in violation of section 1107(a).
Section 1106(b) separately bars self-dealing. A fiduciary may not deal with plan assets in its own interest. It may not act for a party whose interests are adverse to the plan. It may not receive "any consideration for his own personal account" from a party dealing with the plan.
The ESOP exemption is 29 U.S.C. § 1108(e). Adequate consideration is the linchpin of ESOP litigation. For stock with no public market, it generally means fair market value as determined in good faith by the trustee. Cases turn on what the trustee paid compared with what the stock was worth.
An exemption answers only the prohibited-transaction question. Whether the trustee acted prudently is a separate analysis.
Who Enforces These Duties: The DOL, the IRS and Participants
For a participant wondering who can act on a suspected breach, there are three channels.
The Department of Labor. EBSA is the primary federal regulator of fiduciary conduct. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(2), the Secretary of Labor may sue for appropriate relief under section 1109. ERISA also authorizes the DOL to assess a civil penalty of 20 percent of the amount recovered from a fiduciary in a settlement with the Department or a court order, under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(l).
The IRS. The tax code imposes an excise tax on prohibited transactions, 26 U.S.C. § 4975. A "disqualified person" is the tax code's counterpart to ERISA's party in interest. Where more than one person is liable for the same transaction, § 4975(f)(1) makes them "jointly and severally liable."
Participants. Section 1132(a)(2) also lets "a participant, beneficiary or fiduciary" sue for relief under section 1109. That section makes a breaching fiduciary "personally liable to make good to such plan any losses to the plan." The claim is brought on behalf of the plan, and any recovery goes to the plan, not straight to one person. Section 1132(a)(3) separately allows a suit "to enjoin any act or practice" that violates ERISA or the plan's terms, or "to obtain other appropriate equitable relief." Depending on the facts, courts may treat disgorgement of profits as that kind of relief.
Time limits. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1113, a fiduciary-breach suit must be filed by the earlier of two dates:
- six years after the last action that was part of the breach, or, for an omission, the latest date it could have been cured; or
- three years after the plaintiff first had actual knowledge of the breach.
In a case of fraud or concealment, the suit may be filed up to six years after discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts. See the ERISA statute of limitations for how courts apply each trigger.
What You Can Do If Something in Your ESOP Looks Wrong
The first source of answers about your ESOP is the plan's own record.
Request the plan's documents. ERISA gives participants a right to request the plan's governing documents in writing. These include the summary plan description, the plan document, the latest annual report and trust agreements.
Read the Form 5500. The Form 5500 is the annual report an ERISA plan files with the federal government. It shows the plan's assets, service providers and certain transactions for that plan year. Filings are searchable through the DOL's EFAST2 public search.
Know the federal channel. EBSA accepts participant questions and complaints about possible violations through its Ask EBSA page.
Know how private cases proceed. Because relief under § 1132(a)(2) runs to the plan, private ESOP cases are often brought as an ERISA class action on behalf of all participants. ERISA also gives courts discretion to award reasonable attorney's fees and costs. Fee awards depend on the result and the court; none is assured.
A falling share price or a loss in your account is not, by itself, a breach. ERISA does not guarantee investment returns. A fiduciary who followed a prudent, loyal and independent process is not liable for a market-driven loss. What matters is how the decision was made.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.