Braden v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. was a class action in which Walmart 401(k) participants alleged the plan's fiduciaries offered high-fee retail funds instead of cheaper institutional versions. In 2009 the Eighth Circuit ruled the complaint stated a plausible claim, and the case ended in 2012 in a court-approved settlement that included a $13.5 million cash payment, without a liability finding.
If you have money in Walmart's 401(k) plan, or did years ago, and you have seen the case mentioned in an article about fees, the natural questions are what was actually claimed, what the courts actually decided, and whether any of it touched your account. Those are three different things, and the court record keeps them apart. What follows walks through each one in that order.
What Braden v. Walmart Was About
When a lawsuit names your employer's plan, the first useful step is to read the caption and the claims. The case is Braden v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., No. 6:08-cv-03109, filed in the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Missouri. A participant in the Wal-Mart Stores, Inc. Profit Sharing and 401(k) Plan brought it on behalf of himself and other participants. A 401(k) plan is a workplace retirement savings account into which employees contribute part of their pay, often with an employer match.
It was a class action, brought for a group of participants rather than one person. The defendants, as the court's preliminary approval order describes them, were Walmart and several groups of its officers and committees, including a Retirement Plans Committee, together called the "Wal-Mart Defendants," and, after an amended complaint, three Merrill Lynch entities.
The claims were fiduciary-breach claims. A fiduciary is a person or entity that controls a plan or its money and is legally required to act solely in participants' interests. According to the plaintiff's settlement memorandum, a party's filing rather than a ruling, the plaintiff alleged that through a "tainted selection process" the plan offered only retail funds rather than lower-fee institutional funds, that most charged 12b-1 fees, and that all paid revenue sharing to the plan's recordkeeper. The defendants denied any liability or wrongdoing.
The ERISA Duties at the Center of the Case
If you are wondering what rule the Walmart fiduciaries were accused of breaking, it is the general standard every ERISA fiduciary must meet. Under ERISA, 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1) requires a fiduciary to act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries" and for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." That is the duty of loyalty, in § 1104(a)(1)(A). Section 1104(a)(1)(B) adds the duty of prudence: the "care, skill, prudence, and diligence" a prudent person "acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters" would use.
Three terms carry most fee cases. A fund's expense ratio is the annual percentage of assets it charges for operating costs, taken out of returns before you see them. A recordkeeper is the company that keeps individual account balances, processes contributions and withdrawals, and issues statements. Revenue sharing is a payment a fund makes to the recordkeeper out of its own fees, which can give someone a financial reason to keep higher-cost funds on the menu.
The participants alleged that the fiduciaries did not use the plan's large size to obtain lower-cost options. Those were allegations. ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees; the question is the process the fiduciaries followed, judged against the services and alternatives available. More on how that is weighed appears in our guide to 401(k) plan administration fees.
What the Courts Decided: From Dismissal to the Eighth Circuit
For a participant following the news, the rulings matter more than the headlines, because only a court's decision changes the legal position. The district court first dismissed the complaint. As the Eighth Circuit's opinion recounts, it concluded that the plaintiff lacked standing to assert claims based on breaches before he first contributed to the plan, and that he otherwise failed to state a plausible claim.
The plaintiff appealed. In Braden v. Wal-Mart Stores, Inc., 588 F.3d 585 (8th Cir. 2009), an opinion filed November 25, 2009, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit reversed and sent the case back for further proceedings. Applying the federal pleading standard from Bell Atlantic Corp. v. Twombly, 550 U.S. 544 (2007), and Ashcroft v. Iqbal, 556 U.S. 662 (2009), which asks whether a complaint's factual allegations, taken as true, make a claim plausible, the court held that the plaintiff had stated a claim for breach of fiduciary duty.
Part of that reasoning concerned institutional share classes. An institutional share class is a lower-cost version of a mutual fund offered to large investors such as big retirement plans, with a smaller expense ratio than the retail class sold to individuals. The complaint alleged that a plan as large as Walmart's had the bargaining power to obtain such classes. The court held that it was reasonable to infer from the allegations, read as a whole, that the process for choosing the plan's funds was flawed.
That holding was about pleading, not proof. It meant the case could go forward, not that the fiduciaries had done anything wrong. The opinion itself noted that there may well be lawful reasons the defendants chose the challenged funds. The case returned to the district court, the parties began discovery after the January 2010 remand, and the case was later resolved by settlement.
Why the Case Matters for 401(k) Plan Participants
Because you are a participant rather than a party, the value of Braden lies in what it says about how fee claims are tested. The Eighth Circuit's decision addressed the question courts face first: whether a fee complaint survives a motion to dismiss.
Two points from the ruling are worth knowing. First, the court took into account the allegation that a large plan has the leverage to obtain lower-cost share classes. Second, it let a claim about the process for selecting the fund menu go forward without direct allegations about that process, observing that ERISA plaintiffs generally lack the inside information needed to plead their claims in detail until discovery begins. The same process questions arise for every option on a menu, including a target-date fund, a fund that automatically shifts its mix of stocks and bonds toward a more conservative blend as a chosen retirement year approaches.
Other fee suits, such as Spano v. Boeing and Leber v. Citigroup, raised related questions, each on its own record.
The case itself ended in a settlement. According to the plaintiff's settlement memorandum, the settlement provided a cash payment of $13,500,000, to go to the plan to offset plan expenses. It also provided that for two years the plan's Retirement Plans Committee would continue removing retail mutual funds, funds that pay 12b-1 fees and funds that pay revenue sharing to the plan's trustee or recordkeeper. The court's final order and judgment of March 19, 2012 found the settlement "fair, reasonable, and adequate," dismissed the claims with prejudice, and found that the settlement fund "will benefit the Plan" and class members with plan accounts and that the settlement "resulted in significant injunctive relief." The same order awarded class counsel $4.05 million in fees and $231,187.68 in expenses, and the named plaintiff $20,000, all paid from the settlement fund. A settlement resolves a lawsuit without a court finding that anyone violated the law.
Who Was in the Class and What Eligibility Meant
If you held Walmart plan investments at some point, membership turned on the court's definition, not on anything you signed. A class action is a lawsuit in which a group of people with similar claims sue together, so one ruling or settlement applies to all of them.
The final order certified, for settlement purposes, a class of all persons except defendants "who are or were participants" in the plan "who have held assets in the Plan Investment Options at any time between July 1, 1997, to the Agreement Execution Date, inclusive," along with their beneficiaries, alternate payees, representatives and successors. The court certified it as a non-opt-out class under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(1), so members could not exclude themselves. The preliminary approval order did allow members to object, with objections due by February 17, 2012.
In an ERISA fiduciary-breach case, recovery generally runs to the plan itself, and any money reaches participants through their plan accounts under a court-approved plan of allocation. Whether a particular person fell within this class, and how any allocation applied, is a question for the case docket and the settlement notice, not for a general article. Federal court records are also available through PACER.
What Walmart's 401(k) Plan Looks Like Today
When you want current facts about your own plan, the reliable sources are the plan's filings and documents, not news coverage. The Walmart plan is a defined-contribution plan: your balance depends on the contributions made and how the investments perform, rather than on a fixed monthly pension formula. Defined-contribution accounts such as 401(k) balances are not insured by the PBGC, which covers defined benefit pensions.
Each year, the administrator of a plan covered by ERISA files a Form 5500, the annual report that discloses a plan's finances, investments and service providers. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1024(a)(1), it is due within 210 days after the plan year closes, and § 1024(b)(5) requires the Department of Labor to display basic plan information from it on a public website.
No Form 5500 for the Walmart plan was part of the record for this article, so we state no current asset figure, participant count, match rate or fund lineup. Those terms appear in the plan's latest Form 5500 and in the Summary Plan Description, the plain-language document a plan must give participants explaining its rules, benefits and rights.
If Something Looks Wrong in Your Own 401(k)
By the time a participant notices a fee or a fund that seems off, the questions become practical: what can be seen, and how long is there to act. The plan sponsor, meaning the employer that establishes and maintains the plan, and the plan administrator hold the key records.
Under 29 U.S.C. § 1024(b)(4), the administrator must, on written request, furnish the latest updated summary plan description, the latest annual report, any terminal report, and the bargaining agreement, trust agreement, contract or other instruments under which the plan is established or operated. The administrator may make a reasonable charge for the copies. Common warning signs are collected in our explainer on 401(k) plan mismanagement.
Timing matters too. A statute of limitations is the legal deadline for filing a lawsuit. Under ERISA, 29 U.S.C. § 1113 bars a fiduciary-breach action after the earlier of six years from the last act that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the latest date it could have been cured) or three years from the plaintiff's actual knowledge of the breach. In a case of fraud or concealment, an action may be brought up to six years after discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts, and this general description is not a reliable measure for any one participant's situation.
A case review with Employee Retirement Litigation Group is a way to describe what you have noticed and get a fact-specific picture. It is not a promise of any result.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.