Skip to content
ERLG Employee Retirement Litigation Group

Explainer

McGeathy v. Reinalt-Thomas: The Discount Tire Retirement Plan Lawsuit Explained

Published
November 12, 2026
Last reviewed
November 12, 2026
Jurisdiction
Federal (ERISA)

McGeathy v. Reinalt-Thomas Corporation is a proposed class action in federal court in Arizona. Participants in the Discount Tire/America's Tire Retirement Plan allege that the company and its board breached ERISA fiduciary duties by keeping an underperforming target-date fund suite in the plan. The court has made no finding of wrongdoing. The case is currently on hold.

If you work or worked at Discount Tire and saw the lawsuit in the news, you are probably wondering whether something went wrong with money you set aside over years of paychecks. The honest answer today is narrower than the headlines. A complaint has been filed. A judge has ruled that its claims may go forward. Nothing has been proven. What follows sets out what was alleged, what the court actually decided, and which ERISA duties the dispute turns on.

What the Lawsuit Alleged About the Discount Tire Plan

If you have only seen a headline, start with who is involved. The lead plaintiff, Cory McGeathy, filed suit on April 29, 2025, in the United States District Court for the District of Arizona, according to the court's docket. The Reinalt-Thomas Corporation does business as Discount Tire Co., Inc. The defendants are the Corporation and its Board of Directors.

The court's March 5, 2026 order denying the motion to dismiss sets out the complaint's background allegations. It notes that the complaint's allegations are presumed true only for purposes of ruling on a motion. According to the complaint as the court describes it:

  • The plan is a profit-sharing plan subject to ERISA. It is a defined contribution plan, which means each participant has an individual account.
  • The plan provides retirement income for about 16,000 current and former employees and their beneficiaries.
  • As of December 31, 2023, participants had invested almost $1.2 billion in the plan. About $519.5 million of that, or 43.5% of total assets, was in the American Century Target Fund Suite.
  • The defendants kept that suite in the plan for more than 15 years. The plaintiff alleged it is "one of the worst-performing investment suites in the entire market."

On that basis, the plaintiff brought two claims: imprudence and failure to monitor. A second amended complaint filed March 19, 2026 added two more plaintiffs, Zachary Weinshenker and William Karpovich. Every point above is an allegation. None of it is a finding.

ERISA's Fiduciary Duties and Why They Apply to This Plan

When your account sits in an employer's plan, someone other than you chose the menu of funds. ERISA places duties on that person.

A fiduciary is a person or entity that exercises discretionary authority or control over a plan or its assets. The test looks at what the person actually does, not at the person's title. The plan sponsor is the employer that establishes and maintains the plan.

ERISA § 404(a)(1), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1), sets out two core duties:

  • Loyalty. A fiduciary must act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries," for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and paying reasonable plan expenses.
  • Prudence. A fiduciary must act "with the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use."

The Arizona court applied these words in its March order. Citing Tibble v. Edison Int'l, 575 U.S. 523 (2015), it said the duty of prudence covers both the first choice of an investment and the ongoing monitoring of investments to remove imprudent ones. That ongoing duty is why the complaint's 15-year timeline matters to the claim.

The plaintiffs sued under ERISA § 502(a)(2), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(2). That provision lets a participant seek "appropriate relief under section 1109" on behalf of the plan. A broader look at these duties appears in our page on 401(k) plan mismanagement.

Fees, Investment Performance and What This Complaint Focused On

You may have read that cases like this are about high fees. Many are, and it helps to know the terms. In this case, though, the court's orders describe claims about performance.

A few terms used in plan disputes:

  • Recordkeeper. The company that maintains account balances, processes contributions and withdrawals, and issues statements.
  • Expense ratio. The yearly percentage of assets a fund charges to cover its costs. It is taken out of the fund's returns.
  • Revenue sharing. A fund company pays part of its fee to the recordkeeper. Depending on the arrangement, this can offset recordkeeping costs or raise them.
  • Target-date fund. A fund built around an expected retirement year.

According to the court, the American Century suite has nine vintages, one for every five years from 2025 to 2065. The court's March order does not describe a recordkeeping-fee claim or a share-class claim. Its question was whether the plaintiff had compared the funds to a "meaningful benchmark." The defendants argued that ERISA provides no cause of action for underperforming investments. The plaintiff noted that the plan's own disclosure named the S&P Target Date Index as each vintage's benchmark. The plaintiff also alleged five comparator funds.

The court did not decide whether the plan's own index counts as a meaningful benchmark. It noted that courts in the Ninth Circuit are divided on that point. It held that the plaintiff had "plausibly alleged meaningful benchmarks and underperformance relative to those benchmarks," and it denied the motion to dismiss.

The fee concepts are covered more fully in our page on plan administration fees. A plan's annual Form 5500 filing with the Department of Labor reports its assets and its service providers.

How ERISA Class Actions Like This One Work

If you never signed anything, you may wonder how you could be part of this case. A class action is a lawsuit in which a few named plaintiffs ask to represent a larger group with similar claims. A judge must certify that group before it becomes a class. The orders call this a "putative" class action, which means the class is proposed. The docket shows no certification order yet.

A § 502(a)(2) claim is brought on behalf of the plan. Through § 1109, it seeks to restore losses to the plan. Any recovery would reach participants' accounts through the plan, not as a personal award. Section 1132(a)(3) separately allows "appropriate equitable relief." The court's May order notes that the plaintiffs seek reformation of the plan, a remedy the court said would not be available until the end of the case.

Under § 1132(g), a court "in its discretion may allow a reasonable attorney's fee and costs." In class settlements, fees paid from a recovery generally require court approval.

The case has not settled. On May 21, 2026, the court stayed the case, meaning it paused the proceedings, until the U.S. Supreme Court decides Anderson v. Intel Corp. Investment Policy Committee, No. 25-498. The court explained that Anderson "may clarify not only if a plaintiff must plead a meaningful benchmark but more importantly the requirements for a benchmark to be meaningful." It denied the defendants' second motion to dismiss without prejudice, so they may renew it after the stay ends. The docket, read November 12, 2026, shows no entry after that order. The general sequence of these cases is set out in how ERISA class actions work.

What This Case Means for Discount Tire Plan Participants

By the time a case is paused, a participant's practical question is usually what the record lets them check. A few points are settled.

Documents. ERISA requires plans to provide participants with plan documents and disclosures, including the Summary Plan Description, which is the plain-language guide to the plan. Department of Labor rules also require fee and investment disclosures to participants. The court's March order notes that this plan issued a "Notice of Investment Returns and Fee Disclosure." A participant disclosure of this kind lists each investment option's fees and the benchmark its performance is measured against. Form 5500 filings are described on the Department of Labor's Form 5500 page. The agency's Employee Benefits Security Administration also publishes participant materials.

Notices. If a class is certified or a settlement is proposed, class members typically receive a court-approved notice. That notice is the document that explains a class member's rights at that stage.

Deadlines. ERISA § 413, 29 U.S.C. § 1113, bars a fiduciary-breach action after the earlier of two dates:

  1. Six years after the last act that was part of the breach, or, for an omission, the latest date the fiduciary could have cured it.
  2. Three years after the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the breach.

In cases of fraud or concealment, an action may be brought up to six years after the breach is discovered. Which period applies depends on the facts. Separately, § 1133 requires plans to provide a claims procedure for benefit denials. Whether a participant must use that procedure before suing is a rule made by the courts, and it varies by the type of claim and by circuit.

Because this is a defined contribution plan, the PBGC (the federal pension insurer) does not insure these accounts. The PBGC insures defined benefit pensions.

Broader Context: ERISA Excessive-Fee and Performance Litigation in 401(k) Plans

If this case seems unusual, it is not. Claims about fees and fund performance in large retirement plans form a well-recognized category of ERISA litigation, and the Supreme Court has shaped the framework more than once.

Tibble v. Edison Int'l, 575 U.S. 523 (2015), held that the duty of prudence includes a continuing duty to monitor investments. Hughes v. Northwestern Univ., 595 U.S. 170 (2022), held that offering some low-cost options does not by itself protect fiduciaries from claims about other imprudent options in the lineup.

ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees and no fixed performance cutoff. Courts ask whether the fiduciaries followed a prudent process. That includes how they compared options, whether they bid out services, and how they monitored the lineup over time. Courts weigh that process in light of the plan's size, its services and the alternatives that were available. Plan size can affect what bargaining power a fiduciary had.

The pending Anderson case may change how courts in this area evaluate benchmark comparisons, which is why the Arizona court paused McGeathy. Arizona sits within the Ninth Circuit, whose approach is described in our page on the Ninth Circuit. Results in other cases say nothing about how this one will end.

Frequently Asked Questions

It is a proposed ERISA class action in the District of Arizona. Discount Tire plan participants allege that the company and its board acted imprudently, and failed to monitor, by keeping the American Century target-date suite in the plan. The court denied a motion to dismiss in March 2026 and stayed the case in May 2026.

Related ERISA Resources

This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.

Sources

Citations link to free, stable, official sources: the United States Code as published by the House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, the Department of Labor's regulations and Form 5500 filings, and the published opinions of the federal courts.

Last reviewed November 12, 2026.

Concerned About Your 401(k) or Retirement Plan?

The case review is free and confidential. Speaking with counsel early may preserve options that are harder to recover later.

Call UsEmail UsCase Review