Cates v. Trustees of Columbia University was a class action in which participants in two Columbia retirement plans alleged that the university breached its ERISA fiduciary duties and committed prohibited transactions, including claims about recordkeeping fees and imprudent investment options. The court never decided whether those allegations were true. The case settled in 2021, and the court approved the settlement.
If you have saved through a Columbia plan, or another university's 403(b), and saw this case in the news, the useful questions are narrow ones: what the participants actually claimed, which duties the law imposes on whoever runs the plan, what the court ruled along the way, and what a settlement does and does not mean. Each of those has a precise answer in the public record.
What the Columbia University Retirement Plan Lawsuit Was About
Suppose your account statement carries the Columbia name. The first thing to know is which plans the case covered. According to the court's October 18, 2021 order, the plaintiffs sued on behalf of participants and beneficiaries of the Retirement Plan for Officers of Columbia University and the Columbia University Voluntary Retirement Savings Plan.
Both are 403(b) plans. A 403(b) plan is a tax-advantaged retirement savings plan for employees of universities, hospitals and other nonprofits, built much like a 401(k). Columbia's trustees acted as the plan sponsor, meaning the employer that establishes and maintains the plan.
The case was filed in the United States District Court for the Southern District of New York on August 17, 2016, the court's October 18, 2021 order states. The court's order records that a similar complaint filed a day earlier was consolidated with it in January 2017. The defendant was the Trustees of Columbia University in the City of New York.
The court's order summarizes the core claim. Plaintiffs alleged that the defendant breached its fiduciary duties and committed prohibited transactions relating to the management, operation and administration of the plans. A fiduciary is a person or body that controls a plan or its money and must act only in participants' interest. Those were allegations. The court never ruled on whether they were true.
ERISA's Fiduciary Duties and How They Apply to University Plans
When you work for a private university, its retirement plan is generally covered by ERISA, the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974. Plans sponsored by governmental employers, including most public universities, generally fall outside ERISA's fiduciary rules. Coverage depends on the plan and its sponsor.
The duties at the center of the Columbia claims are in ERISA § 404(a)(1), 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1). A fiduciary must act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries," for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." That is the duty of loyalty. The same paragraph requires "the care, skill, prudence, and diligence" that a prudent person "acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters" would use. That is the duty of prudence.
Who is a fiduciary is a functional question. A person is a fiduciary to the extent it exercises discretionary authority or control over the plan's management or assets. A service provider may or may not be one for a given act.
Three terms recur in these cases. A recordkeeper is the company that keeps participant accounts, processes transactions and runs the website, often paid from plan assets. An expense ratio is the yearly percentage of assets a fund charges to operate. Revenue sharing is a fund paying part of its expense ratio to the recordkeeper, which can obscure what administration really costs.
Prudence is not a one-time act. In Tibble v. Edison International (2015), the Supreme Court held that a fiduciary has a continuing duty to monitor plan investments and remove imprudent ones. For more on how these duties work in nonprofit plans, see 403(b) fiduciary breach claims.
Perhaps you have read news coverage describing specific fees or funds. The court's order states what survived the early stage. After the court ruled on the motion to dismiss, the remaining claims alleged that the defendant violated 29 U.S.C. § 1104 by causing the plans to pay excessive recordkeeping fees and by including imprudent investment options.
The full complaint is the place to read the precise factual theories. University 403(b) fee cases commonly raise theories of this kind, each of which is an allegation until a court decides it:
- that a plan used several recordkeepers at once, which plaintiffs in such cases claim weakens the sponsor's ability to negotiate fees
- that a plan offered a more expensive share class of a fund when a cheaper class of the same fund was available. A share class is a version of the same fund with a different expense ratio, often tied to the size of the investment.
- that certain options carried high expense ratios or underperformed comparable alternatives
- that a large plan did not use its asset base to bargain for lower recordkeeping costs
ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees. Courts examine the process the fiduciaries followed, the services received and the alternatives available.
Much of this evidence starts with the Form 5500, the annual report a plan files with the federal government disclosing assets, service providers and certain fees. This page states no figures from Columbia's filings. The questions that arise when fees flow to related parties are covered in retirement plan conflicts of interest.
How the Case Proceeded and What the Court Decided
Anyone who has followed the news may have heard about this case at several stages. Each ruling meant something different. The order and docket record these steps:
- August 28, 2017: the court granted in part and denied in part the motion to dismiss. That ruling tests whether allegations, if true, state a claim. It is not a finding that they are true.
- November 15, 2018: the court certified a class action under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(b)(1). A class action is a lawsuit brought by named plaintiffs for a larger group of similarly situated people. Here the class was all participants and beneficiaries of the two plans from August 10, 2010, through the date of judgment, excluding the defendants.
- March 30, 2020: the court denied the defendant's motion for summary judgment and its motions to exclude the plaintiffs' experts. That sent the dispute toward trial without deciding it.
- March 15, 2021: the court denied the defendant's motion for reconsideration of the class certification order.
- April 7, 2021: five days before a scheduled bench trial, the parties told the court they had agreed to settle.
Because it was a class action, the settlement needed court approval under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e). The court granted preliminary approval on June 29, 2021. On October 13, 2021, its final order approved the settlement "as fair, reasonable, and adequate to the Plans and the Settlement Class." The order directed a settlement administrator to report each settlement payment issued. It also provided that all class members are bound by the settlement agreement.
On October 18, 2021, the court awarded class counsel $4,333,333.33 in fees and $638,367.96 in expenses, both paid from the settlement fund. It also awarded $25,000 to each of seven class representatives. Approval of a settlement is not a finding that Columbia violated ERISA. The case ended without one.
What This Case Means for 403(b) Plan Participants at Other Universities
For a participant at another private university, the Columbia case is one of a number of similar ERISA suits against private universities that began around 2016. The theories of excessive fees and imprudent fund selection were not unique to one school. A lawsuit against another plan says nothing about how yours was run, in either direction.
The statute decides who may sue and for what. Under ERISA § 502(a), 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a), a participant may bring an action under § 1132(a)(2) "for appropriate relief under section 1109," which restores losses to the plan and from there to participants' accounts. Section 1132(a)(3) allows an action "to obtain other appropriate equitable relief." The remedy runs to the plan, not as a personal damages award.
Timing is set by ERISA § 413, 29 U.S.C. § 1113. A fiduciary-breach action must be brought by the earlier of two dates. One is six years after the last action that was part of the breach, or, for an omission, the latest date the breach could have been cured. The other is three years after the plaintiff first had actual knowledge of the breach. In a case of fraud or concealment, the limit is six years from discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts.
A plan's Form 5500 filings are publicly searchable through the Department of Labor's EFAST2 system. Participants also receive plan-level fee and investment disclosures from the plan administrator. What a retirement-plan review looks at is described under retirement plan lawyer.
Key Terms in University Retirement Plan Litigation
If you read a complaint or a news story about your own plan, these terms will come up:
- 403(b) plan: a tax-advantaged retirement plan for nonprofit and university employees.
- Plan sponsor: the employer that establishes and maintains the plan.
- Named fiduciary: the person or committee the plan document formally designates to manage the plan.
- Recordkeeper: the service provider that keeps participant accounts and processes transactions.
- Expense ratio: a fund's annual operating cost as a percentage of assets.
- Revenue sharing: payments from fund companies to recordkeepers that can obscure what administration costs.
- Share class: a version of a fund with its own fee structure. Institutional shares typically carry lower expense ratios than retail shares.
- Form 5500: the annual filing that makes plan fee and investment data public.
- EBSA: the Employee Benefits Security Administration, the Department of Labor division that enforces ERISA.
- Class action: a lawsuit by named plaintiffs representing a broader group of participants.
For warning signs that appear on statements, see 401(k) plan mismanagement.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.