If you held GM stock in a GM savings plan between 1999 and 2006, Pyrka v. General Motors was a class action in which participants alleged that plan fiduciaries kept the GM Common Stock Fund as an investment when it was imprudent to do so. The case settled. A federal court approved the settlement in June 2008 and closed the case.
A GM employee, retiree or beneficiary who comes across this lawsuit usually wants three things answered: what was claimed, whether anything was decided, and whether it touches their account. The court record answers most of that. This was not a fee lawsuit. The filings in the court's own docket describe a company stock case, and what follows is drawn from those filings.
What the GM 401(k) Lawsuit Was About
When you look the case up, you will find it docketed as Pyrka v. General Motors Corporation, No. 2:05-cv-71085, in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Michigan, opened March 18, 2005, according to the court docket. It proceeded as In re General Motors ERISA Litigation before Judge Nancy G. Edmunds.
The plaintiffs were participants in two GM savings plans: the General Motors Personal Savings Plan for Hourly Rate Employees and the General Motors Savings-Stock Purchase Program for Salaried Employees. The court's orders describe them as employee stock ownership plans. In its August 2007 order, the court described the remaining defendants as General Motors and "a number of individuals and committees that oversee certain Employee Stock Ownership Plans." GM was the plan sponsor (the employer that sets up and maintains the plan). Whether any defendant was a fiduciary (a person who controls the plan or its money and must act only in the participants' interest) for a given decision was part of what the parties disputed.
As the court's order describes the plaintiffs' position, GM stock was "an improper investment vehicle for the Plans, given the alleged understatement of future pension and healthcare obligations." The plaintiffs alleged a breach of the duty of prudence by continuing to offer the stock fund.
The court records read for this page do not show allegations about recordkeeping fees or the selection of other funds. Those subjects are explained below because readers ask about them, but they were not the claims in this case.
The Fiduciary Duties ERISA Imposes on a Plan Like GM's
Before you can make sense of the claims, it helps to know the standard the plaintiffs measured the defendants against. It is written in 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1) (ERISA § 404(a)(1)). A fiduciary must act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries" and "for the exclusive purpose of" providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." That is the duty of loyalty.
The duty of prudence requires "the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use." The statute also requires diversification "so as to minimize the risk of large losses, unless under the circumstances it is clearly prudent not to do so," and adherence to the plan documents where they are consistent with ERISA.
One provision matters directly in a company stock case. Under § 1104(a)(2), for an eligible individual account plan, the diversification duty, and the prudence duty only to the extent it requires diversification, is not violated by holding qualifying employer securities. Prudence in every other respect still applies. That is why a case like this turns on whether keeping the stock was prudent, not simply on whether the plan held too much of it.
Courts treat prudence as largely a matter of process: what the fiduciaries examined, when, and why they decided as they did. A bad result alone does not establish a breach.
Excessive Recordkeeping Fees: How That Kind of Claim Works
If you came here because you believe the GM case was about fees, the short answer is that the court record shows a company stock case. Fee claims are common in other 401(k) litigation, though, and they rest on the same duties.
A recordkeeper is the company that keeps the accounts, processes transactions and runs the website. Recordkeeping fees are what it is paid, either directly from plan assets or through revenue sharing (a fund paying part of its fee to the recordkeeper). An expense ratio is the yearly percentage of a fund's assets taken to cover its costs. A share class is one version of a fund; the same fund can come in several classes with different expense ratios.
In fee cases, participants commonly allege that a large plan failed to use its size to negotiate, that revenue sharing inflated the real cost without a visible charge on any statement, or that higher-cost share classes were kept when cheaper ones of the same fund were available. Plaintiffs often compare per-participant costs with those of similar plans in the same period.
ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees. Courts look at the fiduciaries' process, the services bought and the alternatives available at the time. More detail is in our discussion of 401(k) excessive fees and excessive investment fees.
Investment Selection and the Prudent-Process Standard
When a fund in your plan keeps underperforming or a company's stock falls, the legal question is not whether the investment lost money. It is how the fiduciaries chose it, monitored it and decided to keep it.
Courts in investment cases often ask whether the fiduciaries had an investment policy statement (a written document setting criteria for choosing, monitoring and replacing plan options) and whether they followed it. The statute does not name that document; its presence or absence is evidence of process.
Target-date funds (funds that shift their mix of investments automatically as a chosen retirement year approaches) draw scrutiny in other cases because they often hold large shares of participant money and vary in cost and design.
In the GM case, the investment at issue was the company stock fund. The plaintiffs alleged that information about GM's finances should have put the fiduciaries on notice that the stock was imprudent. The defendants argued, in the court's words, that those allegations were "not plausible in light of allegedly uncontrovertible facts." On August 28, 2007, the court granted the motion to dismiss in part and denied it in part, and dismissed General Motors Investment Management Corporation from all counts. Earlier, on April 6, 2006, it had denied the General Motors defendants' first motion to dismiss and granted a motion to dismiss by State Street, according to the docket. Denying part of a motion to dismiss means the claims could proceed; it is not a finding that they were true. For the broader picture, see 401(k) plan mismanagement.
How ERISA Section 502 Lets Participants Sue for the Plan
If you were in the GM class without ever filing anything, the structure of ERISA enforcement explains why. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a)(2) (ERISA § 502(a)(2)), a participant, beneficiary, fiduciary or the Secretary of Labor may sue "for appropriate relief under section 1109." Section 1109(a) (ERISA § 409(a)) makes a breaching fiduciary "personally liable to make good to such plan any losses to the plan" and to "restore to such plan any profits" made through use of plan assets, along with other equitable relief, including removal. Section 1132(a)(3) separately allows appropriate equitable relief.
The relief belongs to the plan. That is why these suits are often brought as a class action (one or more plaintiffs suing for a larger group with similar claims). The plaintiffs' settlement memorandum put it this way: the remedy is "the restoration of losses to the Plans and their participants." Money recovered is allocated to class members under a plan of allocation the court approves.
The court certified a settlement class under Rule 23(b)(1): participants and beneficiaries of the GM Personal Savings Plan for Hourly Rate Employees or the GM Savings-Stock Purchase Program for Salaried Employees who held an interest in the GM Common Stock Fund between March 18, 1999 and May 26, 2006, according to the final judgment.
The plaintiffs' preliminary approval motion, a party's filing rather than a ruling, described a $37.5 million settlement fund and commitments by GM for at least four years, including retaining an independent fiduciary to monitor the stock fund and not making matching contributions in company stock. The court found the settlement "fair, reasonable and adequate." The final judgment awarded class counsel $11,250,000 in attorneys' fees and $175,329.49 in costs. A settlement resolves a case without a finding of liability.
Deadlines come from 29 U.S.C. § 1113. A fiduciary-breach suit must be brought by the earlier of six years after the last act that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the last date it could have been cured) or three years after the plaintiff gained actual knowledge of it. In cases of fraud or concealment, the period is six years from discovery. Which applies depends on the facts. Courts generally require participants to use the plan's claims procedure before bringing a benefit claim. Whether it is required before a statutory fiduciary-breach claim depends on the circuit.
What a GM Participant Can Check in the Plan's Own Record
For a participant reading old statements and wondering what applies now, the GM case itself is closed. The docket shows final judgment on June 5, 2008, and a Sixth Circuit appeal by two individuals that was voluntarily dismissed in September 2008. Questions about a current account are separate from that case.
ERISA gives participants a right to information. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1024(b)(1), the administrator must furnish each participant a summary plan description (the plain-language explanation of plan rules, benefits and rights) within 90 days of joining, with updated versions at set intervals. Participants may also request in writing copies of governing plan documents from the administrator. Plans also provide participant fee disclosures, the statements that break out administrative and investment costs charged to an account.
Each plan files a Form 5500 annual report with the Department of Labor showing assets, participant counts and payments to service providers. It is a public record, and it is the source this site uses for any plan figure.
A balance that does not match expectations, or a charge no disclosure explains, is a fair reason to ask questions. ERISA coverage depends on the plan and its sponsor; governmental and church plans generally fall outside Title I. This site provides information about retirement-plan litigation and plan rights; questions about a particular account call for a confidential conversation, not a general article.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.