Skip to content
ERLG Employee Retirement Litigation Group

Explainer

Byrne v. TIAA: What the ERISA Lawsuit Against TIAA's 401(k) Plan Means for Participants

Published
November 13, 2026
Last reviewed
November 13, 2026
Jurisdiction
Federal (ERISA)

Byrne v. TIAA is a proposed ERISA class action brought by participants in TIAA's own employee retirement plans. The participants allege that the plans' fiduciaries kept plan money in higher-cost R3 shares of TIAA's in-house CREF funds when lower-cost R4 shares were available, and kept an underperforming fund. These are allegations. No court has found them true.

Perhaps you work for TIAA, or you hold TIAA or CREF investments through another employer's plan, and you have seen the case named in the news. The first useful thing to know is which plans the lawsuit is about, what the participants say happened, and what ERISA, the federal law that governs most private-sector retirement plans, actually requires. Once those are clear, it is easier to see whether the case touches your account at all.

What Byrne v. TIAA Alleged

The plaintiffs are plan participants. The court's docket for case No. 1:25-cv-04228 in the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of New York lists a complaint filed by Brian Byrne and entered on May 20, 2025. An amended complaint filed September 3, 2025 names three participants, Brian Byrne, Charles Sullivan and Sarah Johnson. They sue on behalf of the TIAA Code Section 401(k) Plan and the TIAA Retirement Plan, and as representatives of classes of participants in those plans. The defendants are Teachers Insurance and Annuity Association of America (TIAA), the TIAA Board of Trustees, the TIAA Plan Investment Review Committee and John Does 1-30.

The First Amended Complaint states that TIAA is the employer of the participants covered by the plans. It alleges two main things. First, that the defendants invested plan assets in higher-cost R3 shares of TIAA's own CREF funds even when lower-cost R4 shares holding identical assets were available. Second, that the defendants kept the CREF Growth Fund in the plans after what the complaint calls fifteen years of underperforming its benchmark.

The complaint alleges the plans had invested over $2.2 billion in the R3 class compared with less than $800 million in the R4 class as of December 31, 2023. That figure is the plaintiffs' allegation. It is not a finding, and it was not checked against a Form 5500 for this page. The complaint frames the share-class issue as a breach of loyalty and prudence and as prohibited transactions. The defendants have moved to dismiss.

TIAA's Role as a Plan Fiduciary Under ERISA

When a lawsuit calls TIAA a fiduciary, the word has a specific legal meaning. A fiduciary is a person or entity that exercises discretionary authority or control over a plan's management or its assets, or gives investment advice for a fee. That person must act solely in the participants' interest. The status is functional: it depends on what someone actually does for the plan, not on a title.

That matters because a recordkeeper (the company that tracks account balances, processes transactions and keeps plan records) is not automatically a fiduciary. It may become one for a particular act if it exercises discretionary control over that act. Whether each defendant here was a fiduciary for each decision is, by the complaint's own list of common questions, something the court must decide.

The core duties come from 29 U.S.C. § 1104(a)(1). A fiduciary must act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries" and for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." That is the duty of loyalty: no using the plan or one's position to benefit oneself at participants' expense. The same section requires the "care, skill, prudence, and diligence" of a prudent person familiar with such matters. That duty of prudence covers selecting and monitoring the plan's investment options.

Separately, 29 U.S.C. § 1106 prohibits certain transactions between a plan and a party in interest, and certain self-dealing by fiduciaries, except as section 1108 provides. The complaint invokes these rules.

Proprietary Funds and Share Classes: The Core of the Fee Allegations

If you have looked at a fund fact sheet and seen two versions of the same fund with different costs, you have seen what this case is about. An expense ratio is the annual percentage of assets a fund charges for its operating costs, taken out of returns automatically. A share class is one version of a fund. Two classes can hold identical investments and charge different expense ratios.

The complaint's theory is a conflict of interest. TIAA's CREF funds are what the complaint calls TIAA's "in-house proprietary funds," so fees paid on them went to TIAA's own products. The complaint alleges the defendants "continued to offer Plan participants the R3 Classes, which charge higher fees, even after the R4 Classes, a lower-cost share class, of the CREF Funds holding identical assets were introduced to the Plans." It alleges this charged participants more than shareholders outside the plans paid, in violation of § 1104(a)(1)(A).

You may also have read about revenue sharing, meaning payments a fund makes to a recordkeeper or administrator out of the fund's fees. Revenue sharing is a common subject of 401(k) plan mismanagement claims, and cases such as Karg v. Transamerica concern proprietary funds too. The Byrne amended complaint does not mention revenue sharing. It centers on share classes and fund performance.

ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees. Courts look at the fiduciaries' process and at the services and alternatives available. Where a fiduciary causes a plan to pay for its own products, the prohibited-transaction rules in § 1106 also come into play, which is why the complaint cites them.

How the Case Proceeded: Key Procedural Developments

For anyone tracking this case, it helps to know it is still at an early stage. ERISA fiduciary-breach claims belong in federal court: under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(e), federal district courts have exclusive jurisdiction over most ERISA civil actions.

The docket shows the following. The defendants moved to dismiss the original complaint on August 13, 2025. The plaintiffs filed an amended complaint on September 3, 2025. On September 19, 2025, Judge Vernon S. Broderick denied the first motion to dismiss as moot in light of the defendants' forthcoming motion against the amended complaint. On December 15, 2025, Magistrate Judge Robyn F. Tarnofsky denied the defendants' motion to stay discovery as moot, without prejudice to renewal, because the parties were taking part in limited discovery. The defendants filed a new motion to dismiss on October 14, 2025. On January 30, 2026, the docket lists an amended order referring the case to the magistrate judge. On August 7, 2026, it lists a report and recommendation. On September 11, 2026, it lists an objection to that report, followed on October 12, 2026 by a memorandum in opposition. The docket entries do not give the report's text or say what it recommends. As of the docket read on November 13, 2026, it shows no ruling by the district judge on the report.

The amended complaint seeks to represent classes of participants in the two TIAA plans. The docket shows no class certification ruling.

The docket shows no settlement in Byrne. If one is ever proposed, Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e) requires court approval of a class settlement, with notice to class members and a chance to object. A settlement resolves a case without a finding of liability unless the court's order says otherwise.

What ERISA Allows Participants to Do When They Believe a Fiduciary Has Breached Its Duties

A participant who believes a plan was run badly has specific tools under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a). Section 1132(a)(2) lets the Secretary of Labor, a participant, a beneficiary or a fiduciary sue "for appropriate relief under section 1109." That is a claim on behalf of the plan as a whole. Losses are restored to the plan and reach participants' accounts through it, not as a personal award. The Byrne plaintiffs sue under these provisions and ask that the defendants "make good to the Plans all losses."

Section 1132(a)(3) allows a participant to enjoin a practice that violates ERISA or the plan's terms, or to obtain "other appropriate equitable relief." That can include an order requiring a plan to change how it operates. Federal law also generally preempts state-law claims relating to covered plans, which is part of why these cases are federal.

Timing matters. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1113, a fiduciary-breach action must be brought by the earlier of six years after the last action that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the latest date the fiduciary could have cured it), or three years after the plaintiff had actual knowledge of the breach. In cases of fraud or concealment, the limit is six years from discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts.

A claim for benefits is different. 29 U.S.C. § 1133 requires plans to have a claims procedure. Courts, not that statute, generally require participants to use it before suing for benefits; whether it is required before a statutory fiduciary-breach claim depends on the circuit.

What This Case Means for TIAA Plan Participants Today

If you participate in one of TIAA's own employee plans, you may be within the classes the complaint proposes, depending on what you held and when. That does not mean any money is owed. The case is pending, and nothing has been decided on the merits. If a class is certified or a settlement is reached, class members would receive court-approved notice.

If you hold TIAA or CREF investments through a different employer's plan, this lawsuit is about other plans. Whether your plan raises similar questions depends on its own lineup, its share classes and its fiduciaries' process. Coverage also depends on the sponsor. ERISA generally excludes governmental plans, such as many public university and public school plans, and church plans unless they elect coverage.

The plan's own record is the starting point. A Form 5500 is the annual report a plan files with the Department of Labor about its assets, participants, service providers and fees. The defendants filed the TIAA plans' 2019 through 2023 Forms 5500 as exhibits to their motion to dismiss. Participants in ERISA-covered plans can request plan documents, including the summary plan description, from the plan administrator. For another case about a plan's fund choices, see Snyder v. UnitedHealth. For one about a sponsor's own funds, see Becker v. Wells Fargo. Both ended in settlements.

Not every concern about a fund or a fee is an ERISA fiduciary breach. A retirement plan attorney can review a specific plan's record and say whether its facts support a claim.

Frequently Asked Questions

Participants have that right under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a), which lets a participant sue on the plan's behalf for a fiduciary breach. These cases are filed in federal court. Whether a particular participant has a viable claim depends on the plan, its documents and its fiduciaries' conduct.

Related ERISA Resources

This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.

Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.

Sources

Citations link to free, stable, official sources: the United States Code as published by the House Office of the Law Revision Counsel, the Department of Labor's regulations and Form 5500 filings, and the published opinions of the federal courts.

Last reviewed November 13, 2026.

Concerned About Your 401(k) or Retirement Plan?

The case review is free and confidential. Speaking with counsel early may preserve options that are harder to recover later.

Call UsEmail UsCase Review