Karg v. Transamerica was a class action filed in federal court in Iowa by participants in the Transamerica 401(k) Retirement Savings Plan. They alleged that the plan's fiduciaries breached ERISA's duty of prudence by keeping six poorly performing investment portfolios in the plan. The court denied a motion to dismiss, and the case later ended in a court-approved settlement without any finding of liability.
For anyone with money in that plan, or anyone who saw the case mentioned in the news, a useful starting point is to separate what participants claimed from what the court decided. The court record, read through its docket and its orders, draws that line clearly.
What the Karg v. Transamerica Lawsuit Was About
The case is Karg v. Transamerica Corporation, No. 1:18-cv-00134, filed in the United States District Court for the Northern District of Iowa, which sits in Cedar Rapids. In its order denying the motion to dismiss, the court described Transamerica as the sponsor of the Transamerica 401(k) Retirement Savings Plan. It described the plaintiffs as current and former participants in that plan.
The plaintiffs sued as a class, on behalf of all participants and beneficiaries of the plan, for a class period that began December 28, 2012. The amended complaint asserted two counts under ERISA. A fiduciary is a person or entity that controls a plan or its money and must act only in the participants' interest.
- Count one alleged that the defendants' retention of six poor-performing portfolios breached the fiduciary duty of prudence.
- Count two alleged that Transamerica and other defendants breached their fiduciary duties to monitor the performance of the fiduciaries responsible for selecting and monitoring the plan's investment options.
Each of these points is an allegation. None of them is a finding.
The ERISA Duties at the Center of the Case
The law measures a plan fiduciary's conduct against two core duties. Both appear in 29 U.S.C. § 1104, which is ERISA § 404(a)(1).
The duty of loyalty requires a fiduciary to act "solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries" and "for the exclusive purpose of" providing benefits and "defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plan." The duty of prudence requires "the care, skill, prudence, and diligence under the circumstances then prevailing that a prudent man acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use."
The plan sponsor is the employer that sets up and maintains the plan. Here the sponsor was also the company whose name appeared on the challenged portfolios. Courts generally read the prudence duty to continue after a fund is chosen. Fiduciaries are expected to monitor the plan's investments over time and to remove options that no longer belong in it.
ERISA sets no numeric cap on fees and no fixed performance cutoff. Courts look at the process the fiduciaries followed and at the alternatives that were available in context. Two terms come up often in these cases. An expense ratio is the yearly percentage of fund assets taken out of returns to pay a fund's costs. Revenue sharing is a fund paying part of that fee to the recordkeeper, the company that keeps the accounts and runs the plan website.
ERISA covers most private-sector plans. Governmental and church plans may fall outside it.
What Participants Alleged About the Plan's Investments
The court's order names the six funds the plaintiffs challenged:
- Transamerica International Equity Portfolio
- Transamerica Small Cap Core Portfolio
- Transamerica Large Value Portfolio
- Transamerica Large Growth Portfolio
- Transamerica High Yield Bond Portfolio
- Transamerica Mid-Cap Value Portfolio
Plaintiffs alleged that keeping these funds was imprudent. The defendants framed the claim differently. They argued that offering affiliated funds is not itself a breach of prudence. Proprietary or affiliated funds are funds managed by a company connected to the plan's sponsor or provider. They can raise conflict-of-interest concerns.
The court disagreed with how the defendants framed the claim. It held that the plaintiffs' allegation of imprudence "is not based on the challenged funds' affiliation with Transamerica." Under the court's reading, the claim was about prudence under § 1104(a)(1)(B), not loyalty under § 1104(a)(1)(A). The court also noted that the plaintiffs alleged a breach of prudence, "not that defendants conducted prohibited transactions."
This page states no fee or performance figures for these funds. In cases like this, plaintiffs often compare a plan against others using Form 5500 data. Form 5500 is the annual report a plan files with the federal government, and it is public.
How the Case Was Resolved
The case was resolved in two stages.
The motion to dismiss. The defendants first asked the court to dismiss the case, and the court denied that motion. One argument concerned an earlier case, Dennard v. Transamerica Corp., also filed in the Northern District of Iowa, in 2015. Dennard ended in a settlement that included a release of claims. The court also addressed timing. It concluded that the three-year limitation period did not bar the complaint, because the complaint did not show that the plaintiffs had "actual knowledge" of the alleged imprudent process before December 28, 2015.
Denying a motion to dismiss means the court found that the allegations, if true, state a claim. It is not a finding that the allegations are true.
The settlement. The parties signed a Settlement Agreement dated June 22, 2021. The court granted preliminary approval in July 2021 and held a fairness hearing on November 19, 2021. On November 22, 2021, the court found the settlement "fair, reasonable, and adequate, under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 23(e)," according to its final approval order. That same order dismissed the case with prejudice.
The order states that the settlement is "not an admission of any liability of any kind, whether legal or factual." The court's order does not state the size of the Settlement Fund, so no figure appears here.
The Plan of Allocation and the Independent Fiduciary. Two features of the settlement appear in the court's order by name:
- A Plan of Allocation is the document that sets out how a settlement fund is divided among class members. The order refers to the Plan of Allocation contained in the Settlement Agreement's exhibits. The record reviewed here does not reproduce its terms, so the formula it uses is not described on this page.
- An Independent Fiduciary is a party outside the plan's existing management. The court found the Independent Fiduciary's costs reasonable. The record reviewed here does not describe the specific tasks it performed.
The order also states that the court keeps jurisdiction over the administration of the Settlement Agreement and the disposition of the Settlement Fund.
What This Case Means for 401(k) Plan Participants
Three parts of the law frame what is possible for participants in any plan.
Records. Participants have a right to plan documents. These include the summary plan description, which explains the plan's rules in plain language, and annual fee disclosures. Every plan must also have a claims procedure under 29 U.S.C. § 1133. That statute requires written notice of a denied claim, with the specific reasons for the denial.
Remedy. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1132(a), a participant may sue "for appropriate relief under section 1109." A fiduciary-breach claim seeks to restore losses to the plan, and those amounts reach participants through the plan. Section 1132(a)(3) also permits appropriate equitable relief. Many of these claims are brought as a class action, in which a few participants sue on behalf of a larger group with similar claims. The 401(k) class action process follows rules of its own.
Time. Under 29 U.S.C. § 1113, a claim must be filed by the earlier of two dates. The first is six years after the last act that was part of the breach (or, for an omission, the latest date the breach could have been cured). The second is three years after the plaintiff gained actual knowledge of the breach. In cases of fraud or concealment, the limit is six years from discovery. Which period applies depends on the facts, as the Karg ruling itself shows.
Other fee and investment cases follow the same structure, including Spano v. Boeing, Troudt v. Oracle and the Columbia University 403(b) case.
Is There a Current Class Action Against Transamerica?
The court's order describes two related cases, and both are closed. Dennard, filed in 2015, alleged that the defendants caused the plan to invest in funds with unreasonably high expenses and engaged in prohibited transactions. It settled. Karg, filed in 2018, alleged imprudent retention of funds. It settled in 2021 and was dismissed with prejudice.
In both cases, Transamerica appears as the plan's sponsor in the record, not only as an outside provider. That distinction matters. Fiduciary status depends on function: a person is a fiduciary to the extent it exercises discretionary control over a plan or its assets, or gives investment advice for a fee.
This page does not cover any later case. Federal dockets, such as the Karg docket on CourtListener, are public records. Another proprietary-fund case on this site is Leber v. Citigroup.
This page provides general information, not legal advice. Laws and regulations change; consult an attorney about your specific situation.
Attorney Contributor: Charles H. Field
Co-Chair, Financial Mismanagement and ERISA Litigation Practice Group | Licensed in California, State Bar No. 189817
Contributor attribution recognises participation in this website's content program. It does not mean that this page was personally authored, reviewed or approved by the contributor. General legal information only; this material does not constitute legal advice or establish an attorney-client relationship.