Question 1

What is ERISA?

Accepted Answer

ERISA — the Employee Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 — is the federal law that sets minimum standards for most private-sector retirement and benefit plans and requires the people who run them to act in participants' best interests. It covers plans like 401(k)s, 403(b)s, pensions, and ESOPs. It generally does not cover IRAs you set up yourself, or most government and church plans.

Question 2

What is a plan fiduciary?

Accepted Answer

A fiduciary is anyone with discretion or control over a retirement plan or its assets — usually the employer, a plan committee, and sometimes an outside trustee or advisor. ERISA holds fiduciaries to strict duties of prudence and loyalty toward participants.

Question 3

What is a fiduciary breach?

Accepted Answer

A fiduciary breach is when someone responsible for a plan fails to meet ERISA's duties — for example, by allowing excessive fees, selecting or keeping imprudent investments, or putting the employer's or a provider's interests ahead of participants'. Whether a breach actually occurred is a legal determination; our pages describe allegations, not findings.

Question 4

What is the duty of prudence?

Accepted Answer

The duty of prudence requires fiduciaries to act with the care and skill of a knowledgeable expert — and, crucially, to follow a sound, documented process for choosing and monitoring the plan's investments and fees. Courts often focus on whether the process was prudent, not just on investment results.

Question 5

What is the duty of loyalty?

Accepted Answer

The duty of loyalty requires fiduciaries to act solely in the interest of participants — not for the benefit of the employer or a service provider. Favoring a provider's own products over better, cheaper options can violate this duty.

Question 6

What is a prohibited transaction under ERISA?

Accepted Answer

ERISA bars certain dealings between a plan and "parties in interest," such as paying unreasonable compensation to a service provider. In 2025, the U.S. Supreme Court (Cunningham v. Cornell) made it easier for participants to bring some prohibited-transaction claims.

Question 7

What does "failure to monitor" mean?

Accepted Answer

Fiduciaries must keep watching the investments, fees, and providers they select — not just choose them once. Failing to review and replace overpriced or underperforming options over time can be a "failure to monitor."

Question 8

What are excessive 401(k) fees?

Accepted Answer

Fees are "excessive" under ERISA when they're unreasonable for the services provided — often because a large plan failed to use its size to negotiate, or kept high-cost funds when cheaper, comparable options were available. Even small fee differences compound into large losses over a career.

Question 9

What are recordkeeping fees?

Accepted Answer

Recordkeeping fees pay for plan administration — statements, the website, the call center. They should generally be a reasonable, roughly flat amount per participant; courts have scrutinized plans paying far more than comparable plans for the same services.

Question 10

What counts as a "reasonable" fee?

Accepted Answer

There's no fixed legal number — reasonableness depends on the plan's size and the services provided. As a rough reference, large plans can access very low-cost institutional investments and modest per-participant recordkeeping, so paying well above market is a common reason plans get reviewed.

Question 11

What are hidden 401(k) fees?

Accepted Answer

Many costs aren't obvious — they're built into fund expense ratios or paid through "revenue sharing" between funds and the recordkeeper. The result is that participants often pay more than the headline fee suggests.

Question 12

What is an imprudent investment?

Accepted Answer

An imprudent investment is one that a careful fiduciary, following a sound process, wouldn't have chosen or kept — for example, a fund that persistently underperforms cheaper, comparable alternatives. ERISA focuses on the decision-making process behind the choice.

Question 13

What is self-dealing or a "proprietary fund" problem?

Accepted Answer

Self-dealing is when a fiduciary benefits itself instead of participants — for instance, a financial company stocking its own plan with in-house ("proprietary") funds that underperform while generating fees for the company.

Question 14

What's the difference between a 401(k) and a 403(b)?

Accepted Answer

Both are workplace defined-contribution plans, but 403(b) plans are offered by nonprofits — universities, hospitals, schools, and charities. Many 403(b) cases involve too many overlapping investment options and high recordkeeping fees.

Question 15

Why are universities and hospitals sued over 403(b) plans?

Accepted Answer

A wave of suits since 2016 alleged these plans offered too many duplicative options, used multiple recordkeepers, and paid excessive fees. A number of large universities have settled these cases.

Question 16

What is an ESOP claim about?

Accepted Answer

ESOP (employee stock ownership plan) cases usually allege the plan paid more than fair market value for company stock, harming employee-owners. The valuation of the company stock is the central issue.

Question 17

What is a pension (defined-benefit) claim?

Accepted Answer

Pension claims can involve mismanagement of the fund's investments, underfunding, or, more recently, disputes over transferring pension obligations to an annuity provider ("de-risking").

Question 18

Does ERISA cover my IRA?

Accepted Answer

Generally, no. ERISA covers most employer-sponsored plans, not individual retirement accounts you open yourself. Government and church plans are also often outside ERISA.

Question 19

How does an ERISA class action work?

Accepted Answer

One or more participants sue on behalf of everyone similarly affected by the plan. If a court certifies the class, the result — a settlement or judgment — generally applies to all class members.

Question 20

What can participants recover?

Accepted Answer

Recoveries typically restore losses to the plan (and thus to participants' accounts) and may include changes to how the plan is run going forward. Amounts vary widely and are set by the court; per-participant amounts can be modest.

Question 21

How long does an ERISA case take?

Accepted Answer

These cases often take several years, moving through motions, discovery, and sometimes appeals. Many resolve through settlement rather than going to trial.

Question 22

What is the deadline to file (statute of limitations)?

Accepted Answer

ERISA deadlines are strict and fact-specific. As a general rule, claims must be brought within six years of the alleged breach, or three years from when you had actual knowledge of it, with exceptions for fraud or concealment. Because these limits are easy to miss, it's best to ask promptly.

Question 23

Do I have to testify or go to court?

Accepted Answer

Usually not. Most class members are passive and don't testify; the named plaintiffs and experts carry the case, and many matters settle without a trial.

Question 24

What's the difference between a DOL complaint and a lawsuit?

Accepted Answer

The U.S. Department of Labor can investigate and pursue plans through its enforcement arm (EBSA), separately from private class actions brought by participants. Sometimes both happen in the same situation.

Question 25

How much does a case review cost?

Accepted Answer

A case review is free and confidential, with no obligation.

Question 26

What is contingency representation?

Accepted Answer

Contingency means you don't pay attorney's fees up front — the attorneys are paid from any recovery, so you generally pay nothing unless there is a recovery. Confirm exact fee terms with the attorney before relying on this.

Question 27

Is my information confidential?

Accepted Answer

Yes. Your information is kept confidential, and your employer is not contacted without your consent.

Question 28

Will my employer find out, or could they retaliate?

Accepted Answer

Inquiries are confidential, and ERISA prohibits retaliation against participants for exercising their rights. Your employer isn't notified without your consent.

Question 29

What happens after I request a review?

Accepted Answer

A licensed ERISA attorney reviews the details you provide and reaches out to discuss whether you may have a claim. There's no cost and no obligation.

Question 30

Are you a law firm?

Accepted Answer

We are an attorney-advertising and lead-generation service, not a law firm; we connect you with independent ERISA attorneys who may evaluate your situation. See "How This Site Works" for details — and confirm this answer with counsel before publishing.

Question 31

My disability, pension, or life-insurance claim was denied — can I appeal?

Accepted Answer

Yes. ERISA gives you the right to appeal a denied benefits claim, but the deadlines are strict and the evidence you submit on appeal matters enormously. It's important to act quickly.

Question 32

How long do I have to appeal an ERISA denial?

Accepted Answer

Plans commonly allow 180 days from the denial to file an internal appeal — but check your denial letter, because deadlines vary and missing one can end your claim.

Question 33

Why is the ERISA appeal so important?

Accepted Answer

In many ERISA cases, a court later reviews only the evidence that was in your administrative appeal record. Building a strong appeal — with the right medical and vocational evidence — is critical to preserving your options.

Question 34

Which benefits denials does ERISA cover?

Accepted Answer

Long-term and short-term disability, pension benefits, life insurance, and certain severance benefits provided through an employer plan are commonly governed by ERISA.

ERISA & Retirement Plan FAQ

ERISA Basics

Still have questions?

Was your 401K plan named in a lawsuit?

What kind of retirement plan do you have through work?

Was your 401K plan named in a lawsuit?

What kind of retirement plan do you have through work?